How I Met Your Mother's 10 Most Delicious Moments

From the "pineapple incident" to the mystery of the slutty pumpkin, look back at the storylines that gave us food for thought

PUMPKIN SPICE

In season seven, Ted stumbles upon a costume shop with an indecent Halloween get-up displayed in the window – the slutty pumpkin. Having hit it off with a woman wearing the same ensemble six seasons earlier, he tracks down the last person to rent the outfit and comes face-to-face with his mystery lady: Naomi, played by guest star Katie Holmes. Turns out, Naomi has been searching for Ted too, but the sparks both parties experienced in season one fail to withstand the test of time.