• photo | Jake Gyllenhaal, Taylor Swift

Credit: Everett; Curtis Hilbun/AFF-USA

Published: Sunday April 03, 2011 23:00 PM EDT

More from PEOPLE

31 of 309

2011

"Wait a minute, he was in Brokeback Mountain."
– Blake Shelton, speculating about why Jake Gyllenhaal would want to break up with "beautiful" Taylor Swift