• JENNIFER ANISTON photo | Jennifer Aniston, Justin Theroux

Credit: John Sciulli/Getty (2)

Published: Monday November 19, 2012 15:00 PM EST

2012

JENNIFER ANISTON

Jennifer was impressed by Justin Theroux's proposal (a "covert operation") – and her ring. "I had no idea what I wanted," she told PEOPLE. "He just knows what I like."