• JENNIFER & JUSTIN  photo | Jennifer Aniston, Justin Theroux

Credit: Andrea Renault/Polaris

Published: Saturday February 01, 2014 12:00 PM EST



Guaranteed, Aniston will never forget fiancé Justin Theroux's birthday. The actor-screenwriter surprised her during his own birthday dinner in August as the two sipped wine at a corner table at the upscale, understated Blue Hill restaurant in N.Y.C. "It was one of the sneakiest jobs I've ever seen," says the elated actress. "I had no idea."