• JENNY VS. HILARY  photo | Hilary Swank, Jenny McCarthy

Credit: Charles Sykes/Bravo/NBC; C Flanigan/Getty

Published: Wednesday January 21, 2015 06:00 AM EST

2015

JENNY VS. HILARY

We certainly wouldn't guess that these two stars share the same taste in dresses, but as it turns out, the flattering silhouette on this embellished blue Peter Pilotto design works well on both of them. There can still only be one winner, though, so vote below!