•  photo | Donnie Wahlberg, Jenny McCarthy

Credit: Kevin Mazur/Getty; Inset: Corbis

Published: Friday May 16, 2014 06:00 AM EDT


"I thought Donnie was the hottest one but too tough for me, because I was this goody two-shoes. But now when I look at him, I think, 'I'm totally marrying a New Kid on the Block.'"
– Jenny McCarthy, on her early crush on teen heartthrob (and new fiancé) Donnie Wahlberg, to Shape magazine