Credit: Richie Buxo/Splash News Online
Published: Wednesday November 18, 2009 14:00 PM EST
More from PEOPLE
JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE MUST: DESSERT À LA MODE
"Can I go with a multiple choice? At any given moment it could be a blueberry crunch cake, a three-layer pie or peach cobbler. All of these are made by the same lady, my grandmother. And they are all good with ice cream."
