For five seasons of The Hills, Conrad and Jenner led us to believe that they were soulmates torn apart by bad timing. #FBF to 2006, when Jenner told PEOPLE they were "seeing each other" and "having a great time with it." As it turns out, he never did date The Girl Who Didn't Go to Paris – or so he claims. On his podcast in 2014, Jenner said it was all for show … while L.C. insisted they were briefly an item.