The newly-crowned Sexiest Man Alive was spotted in Pittsburgh, Pa., Tuesday – the first time since PEOPLE's big announcement last week.
The actor, 32, was on the set of his new movie, Foxcatcher, which costars Steve Carell and Mark Ruffalo.
The film tells the story of John du Pont (Carrell), a wealthy scientist and philanthropist who suffered from paranoid schizophrenia. Du Pont was convicted of murdering his friend Dave Schultz (Ruffalo), an Olympic freestyle wrestler. Tatum plays Schultz's younger brother.
The Magic Mike star sported a navy suit and striped tie. He flashed a smile and held up two fingers to onlookers. A peace sign or a challenge that he'll go for a second SMA title? We'll have to wait and see!
Tatum's Sexiest Man Alive issue is still on newsstands