SARA & LINDA

To pop the question to girlfriend Gilbert, musician Perry brought The Talk cohost on a picnic with a twist. "The people picnicking next to us pull out string instruments from under the blanket, walk over and they start playing 'Love Song,'" Gilbert said of The Cure track the couple decided would be "their song." During the serenade, Perry donned T-shirts that read "will," followed by "you," "marry," "me" and a question mark. "[It was] magical and amazing," Gilbert gushed.

Beck Starr/FilmMagic