10:49 AM EDT 12/22/2014
Originally posted 04/10/2014 07:15AM
American Idol's Top 8 sang songs from the golden age of Madonna under the tutelage of season 7 winner David Cook Wednesday.
But who recaptured the '80s era of legwarmers, headbands and big hair the best (not counting Keith Urban, who opened the show sporting a clip-on mullet that had Ryan Seacrest calling him "Billy Ray Urban")?
Here are the singers who had "The Eye of the Tiger" and those who were more "Borderline."
Top 5 Most Voted Stories
The Truth Behind Faith Hill's Neck Scar
Kidnapped South African Baby Found 17 Years Later
Lady Gaga Takes the Plunge with Taylor Kinney – but It's Not What You ThinkÂ
Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Police Say
Little Girl with Tumor Has One Final Wish – to Dance with Taylor Swift
Top 10 News Categories
The most buzzed about stars this minute!
Treat Yourself! 4 Preview Issues
More On PEOPLE.com
Got a News Tip?
Send it to our People.com editors!