04/17/2014 AT 07:15 PM EDT
With her piercing blue eyes, majestic fur and overall enviable good looks, we couldn't think of anyone more qualified to help us find the Most Beautiful Cat than – you guessed it – Grumpy Cat.
We put the call out on Twitter, and you delivered with your prettiest kitty glamour shots. When freshly minted 2-year-old Grumpy Cat
stopped by the PEOPLE studio earlier this month to promote her latest collaboration with Friskies Party Mix
alongside her owner, Tabatha Bundesen, we let her judge the cutest, furriest contenders. (Watch the video above to see who won.)
We'd say she was super thrilled with all of the fabulous felines, but let's be real – she wasn't even happy when we showed her
a picture of Channing Tatum
So who's PEOPLE's Most Beautiful Cat? And is the title enough to make said kitty crack a grin?