Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer
Carly has said that Heart is one of her musical influences, so it's no wonder she did a heartfelt performance of one of their most recognizable songs.
PUBLISHED: THURSDAY APRIL 24, 2008 10:00 AM EDT
Relive the best performances from Michael Johns, Carly Smithson, Brooke White and more – then tell us your fave
See Photos
Relive performances by Idol's top female contestant
Relive the 21-year-old contestant's performances
See the Idols (David! Brooke!) and the big names (Brad! Mariah!) who turned out for charity
See how talent translates no matter which language these aspiring stars sing
The singer sets the record straight and tells PEOPLE the song is about someone back home
Plus: Jennifer Garner takes Violet toy shopping, Jessica Biel and more
Plus: Ryan Gosling gives deejaying another spin, Kirsten & Justin Long and more
