American Idol

Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs

Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer

March 5: 'I Drove All Night'

Watch out Celine Dion! Carly sang her power ballad with perfection. Paula told her, "You're like a dependable dog." But Simon couldn't let sleeping dogs lie and gave her an underhanded compliment: "You're a million times better than that song," he said.