American Idol
Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs
Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer
More from PEOPLE
Latest News!
- Angelina: Getting Double Mastectomy Was the 'Right Thing to Do For Our Family'
- Ashley Hamilton: I Struggled with Anorexia and Bulimia
- Ancient Creature with Scissor-Like Claws Is Named After Johnny Depp
- Christoph Waltz Rushed Off French Talk Show After Sounds of Gunfire
- How Sandra Lee and Gov. Andrew Cuomo Do Dinner at Home
April 15: 'Without You'
Carly's powerful voice and wide range made the Mariah Carey song a perfect fit for her. "She's more than doing it justice," the pop diva said of her performance. "She's doing an amazing job."
