American Idol
Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs
Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer
More from PEOPLE
April 8: 'The Show Must Go On'
Inspirational song week was a low point for Carly. Randy and Paula said she failed to connect, and Cowell said her version of the Queen song sounded "angry" and warned her that she "might be in a bit of trouble." Sure enough, she was in the bottom three
