American Idol

Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs

Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer

April 1: 'Here You Come Again'

It's unanimous! The judges – Simon, Paula and Randy – and the week's mentor Dolly Parton thought Carly did an excellent job with this classic song.

More on Carly:

Carly Smithson Leaves American Idol

6 of 10

6 of 10

PUBLISHED: THURSDAY APRIL 24, 2008 10:00 AM EDT

Add PEOPLE Photos to:
My AOL
| My Google
| My MSN
| My Yahoo

Advertisement

Our Favorite Idol Moments

Our Favorite Idol Moments

Relive the best performances from Michael Johns, Carly Smithson, Brooke White and more – then tell us your fave

Syesha Mercado's Most Memorable Songs

Syesha Mercado's Most Memorable Songs

Relive performances by Idol's top female contestant

Jason Castro's Most Memorable Idol Songs | Jason Castro

Jason Castro's Most Memorable Idol Songs

Relive the 21-year-old contestant's performances

More

Idol (& the Stars!) Give Back
| Brooke White, David Archuleta

Idol (& the Stars!) Give Back

See the Idols (David! Brooke!) and the big names (Brad! Mariah!) who turned out for charity

Idol Around the World: The Wild, Weird – and Good!

Idol Around the World: The Wild, Weird – and Good!

See how talent translates no matter which language these aspiring stars sing

The News Now

A-Rod: Madonna and I Are 'Friends – That's It' | Alex Rodriguez

A-Rod: Madonna and I Are 'Friends – That's It'

While announcing new charitable projects, Alex Rodriguez candidly speaks to PEOPLE about the pop star

Don't Miss

Jennifer Aniston's Funny Night Out | Jennifer Aniston

Jennifer Aniston's Funny Night Out

Plus: Tim & Faith's family meal, Amanda Bynes and more

Beyoncé & Jay-Z's Post-Premiere Party | Beyonce Knowles, Jay-Z

Beyoncé & Jay-Z's Post-Premiere Party

Plus: Justin & Jessica's Tennessee homecoming, Ashley Tisdale and more