American Idol

Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs

Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer

April 8: 'The Show Must Go On'

Inspirational song week was a low point for Carly. Randy and Paula said she failed to connect, and Cowell said her version of the Queen song sounded "angry" and warned her that she "might be in a bit of trouble." Sure enough, she was in the bottom three

More on Carly:

Carly Smithson Leaves American Idol

7 of 10

7 of 10

PUBLISHED: THURSDAY APRIL 24, 2008 10:00 AM EDT

Add PEOPLE Photos to:
My AOL
| My Google
| My MSN
| My Yahoo

Advertisement

Our Favorite Idol Moments

Our Favorite Idol Moments

Relive the best performances from Michael Johns, Carly Smithson, Brooke White and more – then tell us your fave

Syesha Mercado's Most Memorable Songs

Syesha Mercado's Most Memorable Songs

Relive performances by Idol's top female contestant

Jason Castro's Most Memorable Idol Songs | Jason Castro

Jason Castro's Most Memorable Idol Songs

Relive the 21-year-old contestant's performances

More

Idol (& the Stars!) Give Back
| Brooke White, David Archuleta

Idol (& the Stars!) Give Back

See the Idols (David! Brooke!) and the big names (Brad! Mariah!) who turned out for charity

Idol Around the World: The Wild, Weird – and Good!

Idol Around the World: The Wild, Weird – and Good!

See how talent translates no matter which language these aspiring stars sing

The News Now

Jessica Simpson's Nerves Take Center Stage in Nashville | Jessica Simpson

Jessica Simpson's Nerves Take Center Stage in Nashville

"If I throw up, I'm sorry," she said before performing her new country songs at a private listening party

Don't Miss

Kate Bosworth's Italian Dinner Party with the Stars | Kate Bosworth

Kate Bosworth's Italian Dinner Party with the Stars

Plus: Jennifer Garner takes Violet toy shopping, Jessica Biel and more

Kim Kardashian's Date with Her Sisters | Kim Kardashian

Kim Kardashian's Date with Her Sisters

Plus: Ryan Gosling gives deejaying another spin, Kirsten & Justin Long and more