American Idol

Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs

Relive performances by the tattooed Irish singer

April 15: 'Without You'

Carly's powerful voice and wide range made the Mariah Carey song a perfect fit for her. "She's more than doing it justice," the pop diva said of her performance. "She's doing an amazing job."

The News Now

Britney Wins Big at the VMAs

Spears takes three Moonmen home – for the first time ever

Don't Miss

Couples Watch: Beyoncé & Jay-Z, J.Lo & Marc ...

Plus: Rihanna & Chris Brown, plus all the latest scoop on star romance

Kate Bosworth's Italian Dinner Party with the Stars

Plus: Jennifer Garner takes Violet toy shopping, Jessica Biel and more

American Idol

Carly's Most Memorable Idol Songs

April 15: 'Without You'

More on Carly:

Our Favorite Idol Moments

Syesha Mercado's Most Memorable Songs

Jason Castro's Most Memorable Idol Songs

More

Idol (& the Stars!) Give Back

Idol Around the World: The Wild, Weird – and Good!

The News Now

Britney Wins Big at the VMAs

Don't Miss

Couples Watch: Beyoncé & Jay-Z, J.Lo & Marc ...

Kate Bosworth's Italian Dinner Party with the Stars