Relive the 21-year-old contestant's performances
Paula Abdul thought Jason – who played guitar for this song – gave a heartfelt performance of this classic from the Lennon-McCartney songbook, but Simon thought it was like a "student in a bedroom at midnight."
PUBLISHED: THURSDAY MAY 08, 2008 11:20 AM EDT
Relive the best performances from Michael Johns, Carly Smithson, Brooke White and more – then tell us your fave
See Photos
Relive performances by Idol's top female contestant
Relive the sweet blonde singer's performances
See the Idols (David! Brooke!) and the big names (Brad! Mariah!) who turned out for charity
See how talent translates no matter which language these aspiring stars sing
Winokur and her husband help deliver son Zev, who was carried to term by a surrogate
Plus: David Beckham's sweet finish to dinner, Miley Cyrus and more
Plus: Gwyneth & Chris's East Hampton date night, Mary-Louise Parker and more
