American Idol
Kris Allen's Most Memorable songs
Relive Allen's performances of Michael Jackson, Donna Summer, Kanye West and more
More from PEOPLE
May 19
Performing at the piano for the final night of performances, Kris reprised "Ain't No Sunshine." "If he doesn't move you," Kara proclaimed to the world, "there’s something wrong you!" Simon told Kris the performance had erased all his previous reservations about him.
