Hottest Bachelors 2009

Single & Sexy Men of 2008

Mario! David! Andy! See the sexy – and available! – men who made PEOPLE's list last year

MARIO LOPEZ

We first met PEOPLE's Hottest Bachelor when he played good-guy A.C. Slater on Saved by the Bell. He's since moved on to Dancing with the Stars and is now co-host of Extra's weekend edition and star of Broadway's A Chorus Line. Still, Lopez, now 35 – here recreating Mark Wahlberg's famous "Marky Mark" pose – says he wasn't always so fit: "I was a fat, fat baby. I looked like a sumo wrestler. My mom had to pull the fat folds apart when she bathed me!"

Want more? Go behind-the-scenes of his bare-all cover shoot in PEOPLE.com's exclusive video, or check out Extra's online special.