Hottest Bachelors 2009

Single & Sexy Men of 2008

Mario! David! Andy! See the sexy – and available! – men who made PEOPLE's list last year

GERARD BUTLER

The 300 star, 39, says he hasn't always had luck with women. "A few years ago, I went out with a girl and we were having a great time. She went to the toilet, and I thought, 'You know what? I'm also going to go to the toilet.' Maybe it took me a little longer to get out of there than I thought. I came back and she was gone. So I said to the waiter, 'What happened?' The waiter said, 'She came out and stood around the table and then she left.' I ran outside and she was nowhere to be seen. I never saw her again!"