He's known for his bromances, but the 25-year-old Hills star is also an expert in the romance department – even if his plans sometimes fall apart. "For Valentine's Day, I wanted to take my girlfriend on a helicopter ride down into the Grand Canyon for lunch," says Jenner, who recreated a Harlequin romance novel cover for his shoot. "But there was a crazy storm. It was an incredible gesture that fell through."
See more Hot Bachelors embrace their inner Fabio in PEOPLE, on sale Friday!