The Bachelorette's Jillian Harris considered Reid Rosenthal the "cuddly, warm guy [she] relates to the most," but when she questioned him about commitment, the Pennsylvania Realtor could only say, "It's hard to throw out the 'L' word." So, the nice guy was sent home in July. "I should have opened up sooner," he lamented as he rode away in a limo. "I was falling in love. I screwed myself."