For Amanda of Everett, Wash., Twilight hits close to home. "It somewhat reminds me of my relationship with my husband, Rob," she told PEOPLE. "We are so different, like night and day, but fell for each other instantly." And it seems Rob agrees – he tattooed the images of Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart onto his wife using a pumpkin-carving template, and even had a "sick masochistic lion" inked onto his leg to match Amanda's "stupid lamb" art. "Instead of putting our names on each other, we did that," she said.