Sexiest Man Alive 2014

PEOPLE's Sexiest Man Alive Trivia

Who was voted Most Handsome in school? Which Sexiest Man sported a mullet? Test your skills in our 25th anniversary Sexiest Man Alive challenge!

  • Which cover star was voted Most Handsome by his high school peers?

CREDIT: Classmates

Published: Tuesday November 09, 2010 06:00 AM EST By: Janet Mock

Correct Answer: Matthew McConaughey

Some people were just born good-looking! As a teen, McConaughey was popular, played golf and tennis, and was apparently the hottest guy in school – according to classmates at Texas's Longview High, where he was voted Most Handsome in 1988. "I got blessed," the actor told PEOPLE of his looks.