Golden Globes, StyleWatch

Jan. 17, 2007 | 03:15 PM EST

Fashion Faceoff: Hilary vs. Jessica

Photo by: Jean CATUFFE / SIPA; NCNA PHOTO
Fashion Faceoff: Hilary vs. Jessica | Hilary Swank, Jessica Biel
Jessica Biel sparkled at the Golden Globes in a glimmering beaded Valentino dress, but it was a familiar look: Hilary Swank wore the same "vintage" dress three years ago for the Oscars. That's a major fashion faux-pas for any stylist – and it's not the first time it's happened. At last year's Globes Reese Witherspoon wore a Chanel dress previously seen on Kirsten Dunst. As for Valentino, reps for the house say that "Valentino dresses are timeless and each woman brings to them her own interpretation. ... Two beautiful actresses can be different and great even in the same dress." Still, you can't help but compare, so who do you think looks better in the gown?

Previous Posts:
Seen & Heard: Cameron and Justin's Fight
Red Carpet Trend: Big Hair